The ‘Wall of Severus’: Pseudoarchaeology and the West Mercian Dykes

Keith Fitzpatrick-Matthews

Abstract


The dates and purposes of Offa’s Dyke and Wat’s Dyke have long been a subject of debate among historians and archaeologists. This paper examines and critiques several of the more unusual claims made over the past century. Prominence is given to the use of ancient literature and widespread misunderstandings of scientific dating techniques, both of which have been used to suggest a Roman date for the origin of the dykes close to the modern Anglo-Welsh border.

Keywords


Bad Archaeology, ley lines, prehistoric canals, pseudoarchaeology, revisionist history, Roman limes, scientific dating

Full Text:

PDF

References


Aitken, M. 1990 Science-based Dating in Archaeology. London: Longman.

Anderson, D.S. 2019. ‘I don’t believe, I know’ The faith of modern pseudoarchaeology, The SAA Archaeological Record 19(5): 31–34.

Arnold, B. 2006. Pseudoarchaeology and nationalism: essentializing difference, in G.G. Fagan (ed.) Archaeological Fantasies: How Pseudoarchaeology Misrepresents the Past and Misleads the Public. London: Routledge: 154–179.

Beamon, S. 1992. Royston Cave: Used by Saints or Sinners? Ashwell: Cortney Publications.

Belford, P. 2017. Offa’s Dyke: a line in the landscape, in T. Jenkins and R. Abbiss (eds) Fortress Salopia. Solihull: Helion: 60–81.

Blair, J. 2007. Introduction, in J. Blair (ed.) Waterways and Canal-Building in Medieval England. Oxford: Oxford University Press: 1–20.

Blake, S. and Lloyd, S. 2000. The Keys to Avalon: The True Location of Arthur’s Kingdom Revealed. Shaftesbury: Element.

Blake, S. and Lloyd, S. 2002. Pendragon: The Definitive Account of the Origins of Arthur. London: Rider.

Breeze, D.J. and Dobson, B. 2000. Hadrian’s Wall (Fourth ed.). Harmondsworth: Penguin.

Carver, M. 2019. Formative Britain: An Archaeology of Britain, Fifth to Eleventh Century AD. London: Routledge.

Collingwood, R.G. and Wright, R.P. 1995 The Roman Inscriptions of Britain I: Inscriptions on Stone (Revised, with addenda and corrigenda by R.S.O. Tomlin (ed.)). Stroud: Alan Sutton.

Corliss, W. 1978. Ancient Man: a Handbook of Puzzling Artifacts. Glen Arm: The Sourcebook Project.

Curley, M.J. 1994. Geoffrey of Monmouth. New York: Twayne.

de Camp, L.S. 1954. Lost Continents: the Atlantis Theme in History, Science, and Literature. New York: Gnome Press.

de Camp, L.S. and de Camp, C.S. 1964. Ancient Ruins and Archaeology. New York: Doubleday

Dessau, H. 1892. Ueber die Scriptores Historiae Augustae. Hermes 27(3): 561–605.

Dimock, J.F. 1868. Giraldi Cambrensis Opera. London: Longmans.

Dumville, D.N. 1984. The chronology of de excidio Britanniae, Book I, in M Lapidge and D.N. Dumville (eds) Gildas: New Approaches. Woodbridge: Boydell: 61–84.

Eagles, B and Allen, M.J. 2018. A reconsideration of East Wansdyke; its construction and date – a preliminary note, in B. Eagles (ed.) From Roman Civitas to Anglo-Saxon Shire: Topographical Studies on the Formation of Wessex. Oxford: Oxbow: 3–99.

Fagan, G.G. (ed.) 2006. Archaeological Fantasies: How Pseudoarchaeology Misinterprets the Past and Misleads the Public. London: Routledge.

Feder, K.L. 2019. Frauds, Myths, and Mysteries: Science and Pseudoscience in Archaeology (ninth edn.). Boston: McGraw Hill.

Feryok, M. 2001. Offa’s Dyke, in S Zaluckyj (ed.) Mercia: the Anglo-Saxon kingdom of Central England. Logaston: Logaston Press: 163–192.

Fitzpatrick-Matthews, K.J. 2001. Wat’s Dyke: a North Welsh linear boundary, viewed 10 February 2020, http://www.wansdyke21.org.uk/wansdyke/wanart/matthews1.htm

Fitzpatrick-Matthews, K.J. 2020. Bad Archaeology. viewed 17 May 2020, http://www.badarchaeology.com

Fox, C. 1955. Offa’s Dyke: A Field Survey of the Western Frontier-Works of Mercia in the Seventh and Eighth Centuries AD. London: The British Academy/Oxford University Press.

Fritze, R.H. 2009. Invented Knowledge: False History, Fake Science and Pseudo-religion. London: Reaktion Books.

George, K. 2009. Gildas’s de excidio Britonum and the Early British Church. Woodbridge: Boydell.

Grant, I. 2014a. Offa’s Dyke De138, Chirk, Wrexham: Survey, Excavation and Recording. CPAT Report no 1224. Welshpool: The

Clwyd-Powys Archaeological Trust.

Grant, I. 2014b. Offa’s Dyke De138, Chirk, Wrexham: Survey, Excavation and Recording. CPAT Report no 1224-1. Welshpool: The Clwyd-Powys Archaeological Trust.

Grigg, E. 2018. Warfare, Raiding and Defence in Early Medieval Britain. Ramsbury: Robert Hale.

Halsall, G. 2013. Worlds of Arthur: Facts and Fictions of the Dark Ages. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Hannaford, H.R. 1998. Archaeological Excavations on Wat’s Dyke at Maes-y-Clawdd, Oswestry. Shrewsbury: Shropshire County Council

Harrold, F.B. and Eve, R.A. 1995. Cult Archaeology and Creationism: Understanding Pseudoscientific Beliefs about the Past. St Louis: University of Iowa Press.

Hawkins, G.S. 1963. Stonehenge Decoded. Nature 200: 306–308.

Hill, D. 1991. Offa’s and Wat’s Dykes, in J. Manley, S. Grenter and F. Gale (eds) The Archaeology of Clwyd. Mold: Clwyd County Council: 142–156.

Hill, D. and Worthington, M. 2003. Offa’s Dyke: History and Guide. Stroud: Sutton.

Houldcroft, P.T. 2008 A Medieval Mystery at the Crossroads. Royston: Royston and District Local History Society.

Jacobs, Z. and Roberts, R.G. 2007. Advances in Optically Stimulated Luminescence Dating of individual grains of quartz from archeological deposits. Evolutionary Anthropology 16: 210–223.

James, P. and Thorpe, N. 1999. Ancient Mysteries. New York: Ballantine Books.

Jones, T. 1971. Brenhinedd y Saesson, or The Kings of the Saxons. Cardiff: University of Wales Press.

Keynes, S. 1999. Offa, in M. Lapidge, J. Blair, S. Keynes and D. Scragg (eds) The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Anglo-Saxon England. London: Blackwell: 340–341.

Koch, J. 2013. Cunedda, Cynan, Cadwallon, Cynddylan. Aberystwyth: University of Wales Centre for Advanced Welsh and Celtic Studies.

Langdon, J.R. 2014. Gigantic Prehistoric Canals: Wansdyke and Offa’s Dyke. Chichester: ABC Publishing Group.

Malim, T. and Hayes, L. 2008. The date and nature of Wat’s Dyke: a reassessment in the light of recent investigations at Gobowen, Shropshire. Anglo-Saxon Studies in Archaeology and History 15: 147–179.

Malim, T. 2020. Grim’s Ditch, Wansdyke, and the ancient highways of England: linear monuments and political control. Offa’s Dyke Journal 2.

Manco, J. 2015. Ancestral Journeys: the Peopling of Europe from the First Venturers to the Vikings. Revised edn. London: Thames and Hudson.

Menzies, G. 2011. The Lost Empire of Atlantis: History’s Greatest Mystery Revealed. London: Swordfish.

Michell, J. 1969. The View over Atlantis. London, Sago.

Millard, A.R. 2014. Conventions for reporting radiocarbon determinations. Radiocarbon 56(2): 555–559.

Mommsen, T. 1898. Historia Brittonum cum Additamentis Nennii , in T. Mommsen (ed.) Monumenta Germaniae Historica Auctorum Antiquissimorum Tomus XIII: Chronica Minora Saec. IV. V. VI. VII. Volumen III. Berlin: Weidmann, 111–222.

Morris, J. 1973. The Age of Arthur: a History of the British Isles from 350 to 650. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson.

Musson, C. and Spurgeon, C.J. 1988. Cwrt Llechryd, Llanelwedd: an unusual moated site in central Powys. Medieval Archaeology 32: 97–109.

Noble, F. 1983. Offa’s Dyke Reviewed. Oxford: British Archaeological Reports.

Nurse, K. 1999. New dating for Wat’s Dyke. History Today (August 1999) 49(8): 3–4

Pruitt, T. 2012. Pyramids, performance and pseudoscience in Visoko, Bosnia, Forum: the limits of collaboration. Osmanagić in the campus. AP: Online Journal in Public Archaeology 2: 24–34.

Ray, K. and Bapty, I. 2016. Offa’s Dyke: Landscape and Hegemony in Eighth-Century Britain. Oxbow: Windgather.

Reeve, M.D. and Wright, N. 2007. Geoffrey of Monmouth: the History of the Kings of Britain. An edition and translation of De gestis Britonum. Woodbridge: Boydell.

Renfrew, C. 1973. Before Civilization: The Radiocarbon Revolution and Prehistoric Europe. Harmondsworth: Jonathan Cape.

Reynolds, A. and Langlands, A. 2006 Social identities on the macro scale: a maximum view of Wansdyke, in W. Davies, G. Halsall and A. Reynolds (eds) People and Space in the Middle Ages, 300–1300. Turnhout: Brepols: 13–44.

Simandiraki-Grimshaw, A. and Stefanou, E. (eds) 2012. From Archaeology to Archaeologies: the ‘Other’ Past. Oxford: Archaeopress.

Simco, A. 1984. Survey of Bedfordshire: the Roman Period. Bedford: Bedfordshire County Council.

Smyth, A.P. 2002 The Medieval Life of King Alfred the Great: A Translation and Commentary on the Text attributed to Asser. Basingstoke: Palgrave.

Spencer, J.H. 1889. Ancient trackways in England. The Antiquary 19: 94–101.

Stenton, F.M. 1971 Anglo-Saxon England. 3rd edn. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Stevenson, W.H. 1959. Asser’s Life of King Alfred together with the Annals of St Neots erroneously ascribed to Asser. New impression, Dorothy Whitelock (ed.). Oxford: Clarendon Press

Storr, J. 2016. King Arthur’s Wars: the Anglo-Saxon conquest of England. Solihull: Helion.

Stover, J.A. and Kestemont, M. 2016. The authorship of the Historia Augusta: two new computational studies. Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies 59(2): 140–157.

Stuiver, M., Reimer, P.J. and Reimer, R.W. 2020. CALIB 7.1, viewed 27 Feb 2020, http://calib.org

Swanton, M. 2010. The Lives of Two Offas: Vitae Offarum Duorum. Crediton: The Medieval Press.

The Viatores. 1964. Roman Roads in the South-East Midlands. London: Gollancz.

Thomas, R.J. and Bevan, G.A. 1973. Geiriadur Prifysgol Cymru, vol II (g-llys). Cardiff: University of Wales Press.

Tomlin, R.S.O., Wright, R.P. and Hassall, M.W.C. 2009. The Roman Inscriptions of Britain III: Inscriptions on Stone. Oxford: Oxbow.

Tyler, D.J. 2011. Offa’s Dyke: a historiographical appraisal. Journal of Medieval History 37: 145–161.

Varley, W.J. 1975–6. Wat’s Dyke at Mynydd Isa, Flintshire. Flintshire Historical Society Publications 27: 129–137.

Watkins, A. 1922. Early British Trackways: Moats, Mounds, Camps and Sites. Hereford: The Watkins Meter Co.

Watkins, A. 1925. The Old Straight Track: Its Mounds, Beacons, Moats, Sites, and Mark Stones. London: Methuen.

Whitehead, A. 2018. Mercia: the Rise and Fall of a Kingdom. Stroud: Amberley.

Williams, A. 2019. Offa’s Dyke: ‘the Stuff that Dreams are Made of’. Offa’s Dyke Journal 1: 32–57.

Williams, H. 2020. Public archaeology for the Dark Ages, in H. Williams and P. Clarke (eds) Digging into the Dark Ages: Early Medieval Public Archaeologies. Oxford: Archaeopress: 1–18.

Williams, H. and Alexander, R. 2019. Dialogues with early medieval ‘warriors’, in H. Williams, C. Pudney and A. Ezzeldin (eds) Public Archaeology: Acts of Engagement. Oxford: Archaeopress: 63–80.

Williamson, T and Bellamy, L. 1983. Ley Lines in Question. Tadworth: World’s Work.

Worthington, M. 1999. Wansdyke, in M. Lapidge, J. Blair, S. Keynes and D. Scragg (eds) The Blackwell Encyclopedia of Anglo-Saxon England. London: Blackwell: 467.

Worthington Hill, M. 2019. Wat’s Dyke: an archaeological and historical enigma. Offa’s Dyke Journal 1: 58–79.

Youngs, S.M., Clark, J. and Barry, T. 1986. Medieval Britain and Ireland in 1985. Medieval Archaeology 30: 114–198.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.23914/odj.v2i0.267

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

ISSN: 2695-625X

Follow us on:

 

 

  

Edited in Madrid by JAS Arqueología