Treaties, Frontiers and Borderlands:The Making and Unmaking of Mercian Border Traditions

Morn Capper

doi:10.23914/odj.v5i0.7735

Treaties, Frontiers and Borderlands:The Making and Unmaking of Mercian Border Traditions

Morn Capper

Abstract

This article explores the complexity and nuance of borderlands and border relations focusing on Mercia. Identifying a host of border maintenance strategies negotiating control over people, places and resources, mitigation of risk and maximisation of opportunity, but also strategic escalation and de-escalation of tensions, the study re-evaluates how Mercian border traditions supported expanded hegemony between the seventh and ninth centuries. The significant departures of the approach presented here are (i) rethinking the traditional focus on military, religious and ethnic identities to integrate these among other activities and experiences defining early medieval frontiers and borderlands and (ii) considering the reimagining not only Mercia’s frontiers and borderlands during its emergence and heyday as a kingdom but also reflecting on how Mercian territory itself became a borderland under the rule of Aethelred and Aethelflaed during the Viking Age, and as such how it was formative in the creation of the Danelaw and of England. The Alfred/Guthrum Treaty and Ordinance of the Dunsaete are here contextualised against other strategies and scales of negotiation and activity framing Mercian/Anglo-Welsh and Anglo-Danish borderlands. Different ‘Mercian borderlands’ are compared in this study and analysed as complex zones of interaction, responsive to geographical factors, but also criss-crossed by multi-stranded pathways of daily life. Mercian borderlands were understood and maintained militarily, physically, spiritually, and ideologically. The article considers how these zones were shaped by convenience but also need and were reinforced or permeable at locality, community and kingdom levels.

Keywords

Aethelflaed; Alfred/Guthrum Treaty; Anglo-Welsh borderland; charters; Danelaw frontier; Mercia; trade; Vikings

Full Text:

PDF

References

Textual sources

Æthelweard, Chronicle The Chronicle of Æthelweard (ed. and trans. J. Campbell), 1962. London and New York: Nelson.

Alcuin, Ep. Alcuin, Letters. In Monumenta Germaniae Historica: Epistolae Karolini aevi, tomus II (ed. E. Dümmler), Berlin: Weidmann, 1895: 1–481

Alfred/Guthrum Laws of the Earliest English Kings. (ed. and trans. F.L. Attenborough), 1922. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press: 98–101

Annals of St Bertin The Annals of St Bertin (ed. and trans. J. Nelson), 1991. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

Asser Asser’s, Life of King Alfred (ed. and trans. S. Keynes and M. Lapidge), 1983. Alfred the Great: Asser’s Life of Alfred and other contemporary sources. London: Penguin.

ASC The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle. In English Historical Documents c. 500–1042 (ed. D. Whitelock), second edition, 1979. London and New York: Routledge.

AU Annals of Ulster 2000. CELT: Corpus of Electronic Texts: https://celt.ucc.ie/published/T100001A/

FA Fragmentary Annals of Ireland 2004. CELT: Corpus of Electronic Texts: https://celt.ucc.ie/published/T100017.html

HE Bede’s Ecclesiastical History of the English People, (ed. and trans. B. Colgrave and R.A.B. Mynors), 1969. Oxford Medieval Texts Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Ordinance of the Dunsaete Noble, F., and Gelling, M. 1983. Offa’s Dyke Reviewed. Oxford: B.A.R.

S The Electronic Sawyer: Online Catalogue of Anglo-Saxon Charters: https://esawyer.lib.cam.ac.uk/about/index.html

VG Felix’s Life of St Guthlac (ed. and trans. B. Colgrave). 1956. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Published works

Abels, R. 1988. Lordship and Military Obligation in Anglo-Saxon England. Berkeley, Los Angeles: University of California Press.

Abulafia, D. 2005 Mediterraneans, n W.V. Harris (ed.) Rethinking the Mediterranean. Oxford: Oxford University Press: 64–93

Abrams, L. 2012. Diaspora and identity in the Viking Age. Early Medieval Europe 20(1): 17–38.

Attenborough, F.L. 1922. Laws of the Earliest English Kings. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Baker, J.T. and Brookes, S. (eds) 2013. Beyond the Burghal Hidage: Anglo-Saxon Civil Defence in the Viking Age. Leiden: Brill.

Baker, N. 2020. An excavation in the inner bailey of Shrewsbury Castle. Castle Studies Trust Report.

Bartlett, R. and MacKay, A. (eds) 1989. Medieval Frontier Societies. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Berend, N. 1999. Medievalists and the notion of frontier. Medieval History Journal 2: 55–72.

Blackburn, M.A.S. 2006. Currency under the Vikings. Part 2: The two Scandinavian kingdoms of the Danelaw, c. 895-964. British Numismatic Journal 76: 204–226.

Blair, J. 1996. The minsters of the Thames, in J. Blair and B. Golding (eds) The Cloister and the World: Essays in Medieval History in Honour of Barbara Harvey. Oxford: Oxford University Press: 5–28.

Blair, J. 2006. The Anglo-Saxon Church. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Blake, M. and Sargent, A. 2018 ‘For the protection of all the people’: Æthelflæd and her burhs in Northwest Mercia. Midland History 43(2): 120–154.

Brady, L. 2017. Writing the Welsh Borderlands in Anglo-Saxon England. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

Brady, L. 2022. The fluidity of borderlands. Offa’s Dyke Journal 4: 3–15.

Brooks, N. 2000. Communities and Warfare, 700–1400. London: Hambledon Press.

Bryant, R., Hare, M. and Heighway, C. 2010. Corpus of Anglo-Saxon Stone Sculpture, X, The West Midlands. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Campbell, J. 1979. Bede’s words for places, in P.H. Sawyer (ed.) Names, Words, and Graves: Early Medieval Settlement. Lectures Delivered in the University of Leeds, May 1978. Leeds: University of Leeds: 34–54.

Capper, M. 2008. Contested Loyalties: Regional and National Identities in the Midland Kingdoms of Anglo-Saxon England, c.700–c.900. PhD thesis, University of Sheffield.

Capper, M. 2012. Prelates and politics: Wilfrid’s influence in the kingdoms of the East Midlands and East Anglia. In N.J. Higham and R.A. Hall (eds) St Wilfrid: Bishop of York, Abbot of Ripon and Hexham. Donnington: Shaun Tyas.

Capper M. 2013. Titles and Troubles: Conceptions of Mercian royal authority in eighth- and ninth-century charters. In J. Jarrett and A.S. McKinley (eds) Problems and Possibilities of Early Medieval Diplomatic. Turnhout: Brepols.

Capper, M. 2020. St. Guthlac and the ‘Britons’: a Mercian context, in S. Tyas (ed.) Guthlac of Crowland: Celebrating 1300 Years. Stamford: Paul Watkins: 181–213.

Capper, M. forthcoming a. The Shaping of Power in Anglo-Saxon England. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Capper M. forthcoming b. Aethelflaed, Aethelred and Mercia: weaving widowhood and warleadership in a frontier polity, in M. Capper, C. Insley, and A. Sargent (eds) Aethelflaed Lady of the Mercians.

Carver, M. 2010. The Birth of a Borough: An Archaeological study of Anglo-Saxon Stafford. Woodbridge: Boydell Press.

Curta, F. 2006. Merovingian and Carolingian gift giving. Speculum 81(3): 671–699.

Curta, F. 2011. Linear frontiers in the 9th century: Bulgaria and Wessex, Quaestiones Medii Aevi Novae 16, Frontiers and Borderlands: 15–32.

Charles-Edwards, T.M. 2013. Wales and the Britons 350–1064. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Christie, N.J. 2016. Creating defended communities in Later Saxon Wessex, in N. Christie and H. Herold (eds) Fortified Settlements in Early Medieval Europe. Oxford: Oxbow: 52–67.

Colgrave, B and Mynors, R.A.B. (eds and trans) 1969. Bede’s Ecclesiastical History of the English People. Oxford Medieval Texts Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Coupland, S. 2023. A coin of Queen Fastrada and Charlemagne. Early Medieval Europe, doi: https://doi.org/10.1111/emed.12640.

Curzon of Keddlestone, G.N. 1907. Frontiers. The Romanes Lecture. Delivered in the Sheldonian Theatre, Oxford, November 2, 1907. Oxford: Clarendon.

Davis, R.H.C. 1982. Alfred and Guthrum Frontier. English Historical Review 97: 803–10.

Dumville, D.N. 1975–1976. ‘Nennius’ and the Historia Brittonum. Studia Celtica 10–11: 78–95.

Edwards, N. 2009. Rethinking the pillar of Eliseg. The Antiquaries Journal 89: 143–177.

Foley, W.T. and Higham, N.J. 2009. Bede on the Britons. Early Medieval Europe 17: 154–185.

Faith, R. 2019. The Moral Economy of the Countryside: Anglo-Saxon to Anglo-Norman England. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Garner, D. 2015. Hillforts of the Cheshire Ridge. Oxford: Archaeopress.

Gardner, A. 2017. Roman Britain from the outside: comparing Western and Northern frontier cultures, in S. González Sánchez and A. Guglielmi (eds) In Romans and Barbarians Beyond the Frontiers: Archaeology, Ideology and Identities in the North. Havertown: Oxbow: 34–47.

Geary, P. 2002. The Myth of Nations: The Medieval Origins of Europe. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Griffiths, D. 2001. The north-west frontier, in N.J. Higham and D.H. Hill (eds) Edward the Elder 899–924. London: Routledge: 167–187.

Griffiths, D., Philpott, R.A. and Egan, G. 2007. Meols: The Archaeology of the North Wirral Coast; Discoveries and Observations in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries, with a Catalogue of Collections. Oxford: Oxford Institute of Archaeology.

Guy, B. 2022. The changing approaches of English kings to Wales in the tenth and eleventh centuries. Offa’s Dyke Journal 4: 86–106.

Hadley, D.M. 2009. The creation of the Danelaw, in S. Brink (ed.) The Viking World. London: Routledge: 375–378.

Hall, R. 1989. Reviewing the Five Boroughs. Anglo Saxon England 18: 149–206.

Hayman, G., Reynolds, A., Coward, F., Robb, J. 2005. A Saxon and Saxo-Norman execution cemetery at 42–54 London Road, Staines. Archaeological Journal 162: 215-255.

Higham, N. 2006a. Northumbria’s southern frontier: a review. Early Medieval Europe 14(4): 391–418.

Higham, N. 2006b. (Re-)Reading Bede: The Ecclesiastical History in Context. London and New York: Routledge.

Hingley, R. 2018. Frontiers and mobilities: the frontiers of the Roman Empire in Europe. European Journal of Archaeology 21(1): 78–95.

Holt, R. 2010. The urban transformation in England, 900–1100, Anglo-Norman Studies 32: 57–78.

Hooke, D. 1983. The Anglo-Saxon Landscape: The Kingdom of the Hwicce. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

Jarrett, J. 2018. Engaging elites: counts, capital and frontier communities in the ninth and tenth centuries in Catalonia and elsewhere. Networks and Neighbours 2(2): 202–230.

Jarman, C., Biddle, M., Higham, T, Bronk Ramsey, C. 2018. The Viking Great Army in England: New dates from the Repton charnel. Antiquity 92(361): 183–199.

Jenkins, D. and Morfydd E.O. 1983. The Welsh marginalia in the Lichfield Gospels. Part I. Cambridge Medieval Celtic Studies 5: 37–65.

Jurasinski S, and Oliver L. 2021. The Laws of Alfred: the Domboc and the Making of Anglo-Saxon Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kelly, S. (ed.) 2004. Charters of St Pauls. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Kershaw, P. 2000. The Alfred‐Guthrum Treaty. Scripting accommodation and interaction in Viking‐Age England, in D.M. Hadley and J.D. Richards (eds) Cultures in Contact: Scandinavian Settlement in England in the Ninth and Tenth Centuries. Turnhout: Brepols: 43–64.

Kershaw J. 2013. Viking Identities: Scandinavian Jewellery in England. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Keynes, S.D. 1994. The West Saxon charters of King Aethelwulf and his sons. English Historical Review 109 (403): 1109–1149.

Keynes, S. 2005. Mercia and Wessex in the ninth century, in M.P. Brown and C.A. Farr (eds) Mercia: An Anglo-Saxon Kingdom in Europe. London: Continuum: 311–328.

Keynes, S.D. 2001. Edward, King of the Anglo-Saxons, in N.J. Higham and D.H. Hill (eds) Edward the Elder, 899–924. London: Routledge: 40–66.

Keynes, S.D. and Lapidge, M. (ed.) 1983. Alfred the Great: Asser’s Life of Alfred and other Contemporary Sources. London: Penguin.

Lane, A. and Redknap, M. 2019. Llangorse Crannog: The Excavation of an Early Medieval Royal Site in the Kingdom of Brycheiniog. Oxford: Oxbow.

Langlands, A. 2019. The Ancient Ways of Wessex Oxford: Windgather.

Lavelle, R. 2010. The politics of rebellion: the aetheling Aethelword and West Saxon royal succession, in P. Skinner (ed.) Challenging the Boundaries of Medieval History. Turnhout: Brepols: 51–80.

Lewis, C.P. and Thacker, A.T. (eds). 2003. A History of the County of Chester: Volume 5 Part 1, the City of Chester: General History and Topography. London: Victoria County History. 16–33.

Lieberman, M. 2010. The Medieval March of Wales: The Creation and Perception of a Frontier, 1066–1283. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Lightfoot, K.G. and Martinez, A. 1995. Frontiers and boundaries in archaeological perspective. Annual Review of Anthropology 24: 471–492.

Lyon, S. 2001. The coinage of Edward the Elder, in N.J. Higham and D.H. Hill (eds) Edward the Elder 899–924. London: Routledge: 67–78.

Lyons, A.W. and Mackay W.J. 2008. The Lunettes coinage of Alfred the Great. British Numismatic Journal 78: 38–110.

Madicott, J.R. 2005. London and Droitwich, c. 650—750: trade, industry and the rise of Mercia. Anglo-Saxon England 34: 7–58.

Malim,T. and Hayes, L. 2008. The date and nature of Wat’s Dyke: a reassessment in the light of recent investigations at Gobowen, Shropshire. Anglo Saxon Studies in Archaeology and History 15: 147–179.

Mason, D.J.P. (ed.) 2005. Excavations at Chester: The Roman Fortress Baths, Excavations and Recording 1732–1998. Archaeological Service Excavation and Survey Report 13. Chester: Chester City Council.

Mason, D.J.P. 2007. Chester AD 400–1066: From Roman Fortress to English Town. Stroud: Tempus.

McWirr, A., Viner, L. and Wells, C. 1982. Romano-British Cemeteries at Cirencester. Cirencester Excavations II. Cotswold Archaeological Trust.

Murrieta-Flores, P. and Williams, H. 2017. Placing the Pillar of Eliseg: movement, visibility and memory in the early medieval landscape. Medieval Archaeology 61(1): 69–103.

Molyneaux, G. 2012. The Ordinance concerning the Dunsaete and the Welsh frontier in the late tenth and eleventh centuries. Anglo-Saxon England 40: 249–272.

Molyneaux, G. 2015. The Formation of the English Kingdom in the Tenth Century. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Naum, M. 2012. Difficult middles, hybridity and ambivalence of a medieval frontier: the cultural landscape of Lolland and Falster (Denmark). Journal of Medieval History, 38(1) 56–75.

Naismith, R. 2017. Medieval European Coinage: With a Catalogue of Coins at the Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge 8: Britain and Ireland, c. 400-1066. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Naismith, R. 2022. Big Habban: An introduction to money trade and cross-border traffic. Offa’s Dyke Journal 4: 16–35.

Parsons, D. 2022. Place-names and Offa’s Dyke: The limits of inference. Offa’s Dyke Journal 4: 107–131.

Pears, B., Brown, A. G., Carroll, J., Toms, P., Wood, J. and Jones, R. 2020. Early medieval place-names and riverine flood histories: A new approach and new chronostratigraphic records for three English rivers. European Journal of Archaeology 23(3): 381–405.

Pelkmans, M. and Umetbaeva, D. 2018. Stuff of boundaries? Kyrgyz–Russian marriages and the actualization of ethnic difference, History and Anthropology 29(5): 541–562.

Petts, D. 2013. Military and civilian: Reconfiguring the end of Roman Britain in the North. European Journal of Archaeology 16(2): 314–335.

Power, D. 1999. Frontiers: terms, concepts, and the historians of medieval and early modern Europe, in D. Power and N. Standen (eds) 1999. Frontiers in Question: Eurasian Borderlands, 700–1700. Basingstoke: Macmillan: 1–12.

Pratt D. 2007. The political thought of King Alfred the Great. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Ray, K. and Bapty, I. 2016. Offa’s Dyke: Landscape and Hegemony in Eighth-Century Britain. Oxford: Windgather.

Ray, K. and Delaney, L. 2018. Breinton, Breinton House. Transactions of the Woolhope Naturalists’ Field Club 66: 156–157.

Ray, K. 2022. The organisation of the mid-Late Anglo-Saxon borderland with Wales, Offa’s Dyke Journal 4: 132–153.

Reynolds, A. and Langlands, A. 2006. Social identities on the macro scale: a maximum view of Wansdyke. in W. Davies, G. Halsall and A. Reynolds (eds) People and Space in the Middle Ages, 300–1300. Turnhout: Brepols: 13–44.

Reynolds, A. 2009. Anglo-Saxon Deviant Burial Customs. Medieval History and Archaeology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Richards, J.D., Beswick, P., Bond, J., Jecock, M., McKinley, J., Rowland, S. and Worley, F. 2004. Excavations at the Viking barrow cemetery at Heath Wood, Ingleby, Derbyshire. The Antiquaries Journal 84: 23–116.

Rumford, C. 2013 Towards a vernacularized border studies: the case of citizen borderwork. Journal of Borderlands Studies 28(2): 169–180.

Sawyer, P.H. 1989. Charters of Burton Abbey: Anglo-Saxon Charters II. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Sims-Williams, P. 1990. Religion and Literature in Western England, 600–800. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Sims-Williams, P. 2019. The Book of Llandaf as a Historical Source. Woodbridge: Boydell.

Stafford, P. 2005. Political women in Mercia, in M.P. Brown and C.A. Farr (eds) Mercia: an Anglo-Saxon Kingdom in Europe. London: Continuum: 35–49.

Stafford, P. 2008. The Annals of Æthelflæd: annals, history and politics in early tenth-century England. In J. Barrow and A. Wareham (eds) Myth, Rulership, Church and Charters: Essays in Honour of Nicholas Brooks. Aldershot: Ashgate: 101–116.

Stenton, F.M. 1971. Anglo-Saxon England, third edition. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Story, J. 2005. Charlemagne Empire and Society. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

Thacker, A. 1985. Kings, Saints and Monasteries in pre-Viking Mercia. Midland History 10: 1–25.

Turner, F.J. 1921. The Frontier in American History. New York: Bolt & Co.

Tyler, D. 2011. Offa’s dyke: A historiographical appraisal. Journal of Medieval History 37(2): 145–161.

Vohra, P. 2016. One of us? Negotiating multiple legal identities across the Viking diaspora. Ethnic and Racial Studies 39(2): 204–222.

Wallace, Patrick 1992. The archaeological identity of the Hiberno-Norse town. The Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland 122: 35–66.

Ward, S.W., Mason, D.J.P., McPeake, J., and Carrington, P. 2012. Excavations at Chester: The Western and Southern Roman Extramural Settlements : A Roman Community on the Edge of the World: Excavations 1964–1989 and Other Investigations. Oxford: Archaeopress.

Whitelock, D. 1941. Wulfstan and the so–called Laws of Edward and Guthrum. English Historical Review 56(221): 1–21.

Whittock, H. 2012. The annexation of Bath by Wessex: the evidence of two rare coins of Edward the Elder. British Numismatic Journal 82: 46–53.

Williams, H. 2021 Rethinking Wat’s Dyke: a monument’s flow in a hydraulic frontier zone. Offa’s Dyke Journal 3: 151–182.

Wilmott, T. and Garner, D. 2018. Excavations at Chester Amphitheatre, Volume I: The Prehistoric and Roman Archaeology. Oxford: Oxbow.

Woolf, A. 2007. Apartheid and economics in Anglo-Saxon England, in N.J. Higham (ed.) Britons in Anglo-Saxon England. Woodbridge: Boydell: 130–143.

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.23914/odj.v5i0.7735

Refbacks

There are currently no refbacks.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

ISSN: 2695-625X

Edited in Madrid by JAS Arqueología